Friday, September 14, 2012

URJ Virtual Symposium on Jewish Education:
Revolution AND Evolution

Two postings today on the RJ.org Virtual Symposium on Jewish Education. I am honored to have been invited to submit a response to Dr. Edelsberg's initial posting. As before, please comment on the RJ.org blog, so that we are all part of the same conversation!


I am so pleased that this symposium began with Dr. Charles Edelsberg’s words, as I have known of and benefited from his vision as realized through his work with the Jim Joseph Foundation. He writes,
“[We] must begin with the understanding that education does not equal schooling. In fact, the very place of Jewish institutions as centers of Jewish teaching and learning – day and congregational schools perhaps most prominent among them – must be called into question by any earnest futurist.”
Reading this, I felt a visceral response. After all, I have dedicated my life to being a synagogue educator. Then I took a breath and remembered that for the past several years I have been saying more or less the same thing. We do need to question how learning is best transmitted. In fact, we need to question the language we use in the entire endeavor.

At the same time, I also question those who have already decided the answer is to jettison the schools – and the synagogues for that matter – and find the new new thing, to borrow a phrase from Michael Lewis. We do need to find the new new thing, but I don’t think that means jettisoning the models we have.

We need to transform our schools. And for a visionary idea, I look to the past, to John Dewey. As recently as 1897, he said:
I believe that the only true education comes through the stimulation of the child’s powers by the demands of the social situations in which he finds himself… I believe that the school is primarily a social institution… I believe that the school must represent present life-life as real and vital to the child as that which he carries on in the home, in the neighborhood, or on the playground.
So when Dr. Edelsberg invokes the idea that “profound revolutions in information and communications technologies are accelerating deep learning outside of formal institutional settings – occurring in real time, all the time,” he is restating Dewey. It is the same as it ever was, and we need to be constantly adapting how learning happens in our congregations.

To me, the focus is on creating community and relationship. While the self-direct approach will serve some better than anything we have done before, I believe it must – particularly for younger learners – be a component of the learning experience, not the totality.

For the last few years at Congregation B’nai Israel in Bridgeport, CT, we have been trying to focus on relationship building. While our school is still a school, it is not monolithic and unchanging. This past spring, a parent emailed to explain that the timing of school as her daughter moved to a new grade was not going to work – and because we couldn’t help her, they were going to “do it on their own.” Another parent expressed concern with the content and the methodology of the program – and because we couldn’t help her, they were going to “do it on their own.” We invited both to bring their concerns to and join our Religious School Vision Team. 

On September 9, we opened our fully subscribed Etgar class, a pilot program that meets the challenge of logistics, integrates Hebrew and Judaic learning and brings experiential learning to the forefront – all in response to the needs we helped our families articulate.

It comes down to relationships. Between adults. Between children. Between congregational leadership, professionals, and our congregants. My wife, a healthcare marketing professional, told me once that all problems are ultimately communications problems. Sometimes we don’t ask the right questions; sometimes we don’t correctly hear the answers or questions directed to us. Instead of meeting the needs we think people have, we need to focus on the needs they really have.

One of the ways we do that in our temple is through organizing the parents to help them build their own relationships in the context of the congregation. In Torah at the Center (page 6), our Room Parent Coordinator Amy Newman described how our room parents don’t do what traditional room parents do. Their role is to get the parents of the students to socialize and build relationships. Parents of older students create programs that get our students to do the same.

My teacher Jerry Kaye, director of URJ Olin Sang Ruby Union Institute, teaches his staff that “camp is for the campers.” That means that all activity (not just teaching) must be designed with, as Dr. Edelsberg says, “personal relevance to the learner foremost in mind.” I use the same teaching with my faculty: Everything we do is in service of the learner’s experience and that of her family – not the experience we think they should have, but the one they have come to expect, because we developed it together.

Dr. Edelsberg gives us a lot to chew on. And we have to both embrace where have been and let go enough to bring in other possibilities. Soon, we will be asking students to turn their phones on at the start of class, so they can bring the world in with them – and so they can go out into the world and bring their classmates with them, as well.

Ira J. Wise, RJE, is the director of education at Congregation B’nai Israel in Bridgeport, CT. He blogs about Jewish Education at Welcome to the Next Level and first met Dr. Charles Edelsberg as a Jim Joseph Foundation Fellow at the Lookstein Institute for Jewish Education in the Diaspora at Bar Ilan University. He is a graduate of the Rhea Hirsch School of Education at HUC-JIR.

12 comments:

  1. I had spent so much time for searching information on this topic. But, a small number of sites I have found. In those, this one helped me a lot. Thanks for sharing wonderful information. If you want to know more about this topic, then click on the below links.
    Thank You!

      Trading
     Future Market
      international trade
     US dollar

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is really quality & outstanding post. keep it up!

    Latest stock market news and updates on the stockinvestor...buy or sell stock ideas by experts for minute to minute updates...
    Currency Trading

    Stock Trading

    Demat Account

    Share Trading

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is really quality & outstanding post. keep it up!

    Latest stock market news and updates on the stockinvestor...buy or sell stock ideas by experts for minute to minute updates...
    Currency Trading

    Stock Trading

    Demat Account

    Share Trading

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great Information! Its looking Nice.Useful for me to develop my knowledge. Thank you!

    You can invest in stocks yourself by buying individual Stocks & Shares or mutual funds,IPOs, or get help investing in stocks by Visit stockinvestor.in

    Demat Account

    ShareTrading

    Equity Trading

    Stock Trading

    ReplyDelete
  5. I saw your post. it has very good information keep it up. we are also stock market company we provide good stock tips and Stock market Live news...etc

    Forex Trading

    ShareTrading

    Trading

    Stock Trading

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great job for publishing such a beneficial web site. Your web log isn’t only useful but it is additionally really creative too.
    check these links for more relevant content related to your blog
       Forex Market
     Financial Market
      Currency Pairs
     Currency Trading

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great Information! Its looking Nice.....

    You can invest in stocks yourself by buying individual Stocks & Shares or mutual funds,IPOs, or get help investing in stocks by Visit stockinvestor.in
    phillips carbon share price
    shakti pumps share price
    ramco industries
    mahindra amc
    bajaj electricals share price
    kolte patil developers ltd
    sbi insurance
    bsesensex

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great read! As usual helpful always.
    Thanks for sharing your valuable information. But i have a quation. How can I make money with stock trading?

    muthoot forex
    phoenix mills share price
    beml share
    phoenix mills share price
    tata investment share price
    nse berger paint
    equitas
    nse berger paint

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks for such a valuable and informative platform I find here.
    wish to learn more about stock market and stock/share market Live Updates from this site (stockinvestor.in)

    lic housing finance share price target
    tata power stock recommendation
    amarraja batteries
    jm financial share
    phillips carbon share price
    balrampur chini mills
    relaxo chappals
    bioscon ltd

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for such a valuable and informative platform I find here.
    wish to learn more about stock market and stock/share market Live Updates from this site (stockinvestor.in)

    lic housing finance share price target
    tata power stock recommendation
    amarraja batteries
    jm financial share
    phillips carbon share price
    balrampur chini mills
    relaxo chappals
    bioscon ltd

    ReplyDelete
  11. Nice Article. Thank you for sharing the informative article with us.
    This post is helpful to many people. stockinvestor.in is a stock related website which provides all stocks related information like new stocks and shares available in the stock market.
    petronet lng share price
    havells india share price

    ReplyDelete
  12. Good Post Keep it up thanks for sharing the information.
    How long do I plan to invest?
    ashok leyland share price target

    ReplyDelete

ShareThis